...

Many investors realise their fund isn’t giving adequate returns or risk-adjusted returns, yet stay put to avoid an exit load. That is usually the wrong call. A rational investor should be willing to absorb a loss and move to a better product. Use a zero-based approach: evaluate every holding afresh, as if you were investing today. In an underperforming fund, a lower NAV also means a lower exit load. No product guarantees returns.

Most investors don’t review their portfolio until something hurts. And even when they see a fund lagging year after year, they hesitate to act, because exiting means paying a fee and booking a loss. This guide explains why that hesitation can be costly, and how to decide whether to hold or switch.

According to the team at Chanakya Capital, a SEBI-registered portfolio manager, “an investor ought to be rational and willing to absorb losses in order to move to better investment products.”

Not sure whether your current holdings deserve to stay? Talk to Chanakya Capital’s team.

Why Investors Hesitate to Exit a Poor Fund

The Core Strengths

A SIP is useful because of four things:

  • Discipline: it invests a fixed amount on a fixed date, regardless of headlines
  • Habit building: saving and investing become automatic, not occasional
  • Low entry point: many fund SIPs begin at a few hundred rupees a month
  • Institutional planning: steady instalments let institutions plan their investment strategy on a continuous basis

The Limits

A SIP does not guarantee returns, protect you from a falling market, or rescue a weak investment. It decides how you buy, not what you buy.

Why Many SIP Investors Have Earned Little Recently

The Fear of Exit Load

Many investors realise that their investments haven’t been giving adequate returns or risk-adjusted returns. Yet in many instances they are reluctant to switch, because they would have to pay an exit load. The fee feels like a certain, visible loss, while the cost of staying in a weak fund is silent and spread over years.

The Pain of Booking a Loss

Selling below your purchase price makes the loss real. So investors wait for the NAV to “come back” before exiting. But a fund’s past price is irrelevant to its future performance. Waiting to break even often means missing the recovery that a better fund could have delivered in the meantime.

Why Staying Put Can Cost More Than Leaving

Averaging Out Returns Hides Poor Performance

If investors never switch, investment houses face no pressure to improve. They can keep justifying poor performance by pointing to returns averaged out over long periods. Your willingness to move is the only real accountability a fund has.

A Lower NAV Means a Lower Exit Load

Here is a point many investors miss. In the case of an underperforming investment vehicle, a lower NAV would mean a lower exit load, since the load is charged on the redemption value. The fee on a struggling fund is therefore usually smaller than it feels. Compare it with the cost of staying invested for another two or three years in a weak performer.

Adopt a Zero-Based Approach to Every Holding

As in any other aspect of life, investors should adopt a zero-based approach and evaluate each holding afresh. This is a core idea behind Chanakya’s first-principles investing: judge an asset on its merits today, not on what you paid for it or how long you have held it.

Questions to Ask About Each Fund

  • If I had this money in cash today, would I buy this fund?
  • Are its returns and risk-adjusted returns adequate versus its benchmark and peers across market cycles?
  • Has the investment process or fund management team changed?
  • What is the exit load, and how does it compare with the likely cost of staying?

Wiser to Switch, Even at a Cost

This may even mean booking losses on a decline in NAV and paying an exit load. But it is wiser to shift money to a better-performing fund than to hold a weak one out of habit. Sunk cost is not a reason to stay invested.

Applying This Across MF, AIF and PMS

The principle holds for every vehicle:

  • Mutual funds: compare returns against the benchmark and category peers, and check how the exit load is structured
  • AIFs: these often have lock-ins and specific terms, so read the documents carefully before exiting
  • Portfolio management services: since stocks sit in your own demat account, review holdings, fees and the manager’s track record regularly

Please note that exit terms and tax treatment differ by product, so confirm them with your advisor before switching.

Hold or Switch? A Simple Guide

  • Hold if the fund has performed adequately across cycles and its process is unchanged
  • Switch if returns and risk-adjusted returns are persistently inadequate, even after considering the exit load

Want a fresh, unbiased review of your current investments? Schedule a consultation with our fund management team.

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Should I wait for the NAV to recover before selling an underperforming fund?

Not necessarily. Past NAV has no bearing on future returns. Evaluate the fund afresh, and switch if a better option exists.

2. Is exit load a good reason to stay in a poor fund?

Usually not. In an underperforming fund, a lower NAV means a lower exit load, and the fee is often smaller than the cost of staying.

3. What is a zero-based approach to investing?

It means evaluating each holding afresh, as if you were making the investment today, ignoring your purchase price and holding period.

4. How do I know if my fund is underperforming?

Compare its returns and risk-adjusted returns with its benchmark and peers over full market cycles, not just one year.

5. Does switching to a new fund guarantee better returns?

No. All investments carry market risk. Switching improves your odds only if the new fund has a sound process, but it cannot guarantee profits.

References

Disclaimer: Investments in securities markets are subject to market risks. Please read all related documents carefully before investing.

Call Now Button Seraphinite AcceleratorOptimized by Seraphinite Accelerator
Turns on site high speed to be attractive for people and search engines.